who did invite people like this "shabeeb" to celebrate birthday of (S.A) ? who did that nonsense? Anyhow it is known that anybody can celebrate his birthday, it may not be a sunnath though. And u know what....who celebrates the birthday of EMS? most likely CPI activists and not any Congress guys, right? like that who will celebrate Allah's prophet's birthday ? y doubt... Muslims !!! who are satisfied with Islam... Have u guys seen any X-ian or Hindu celebrating our loving Prophet's birthday ? I guess u havent' coz it is not their concern !!!
shak380
9/23/2008
2
If all things came after the time of The messenger صلى الله عليه وسلم are Bid'aath, the new systems of our islamic teachinng (like colleges and Madrassas) and even the teaching of Hadeeth of the prophet should be considered as Bid'ath. Really they are not Bid'ath. Then there should be a criterion for assigning the name Bid'ath to any thing that came after The messenger صلى الله عليه وسلم
Salam
4/5/2008
3
Why should we celebrate birthday of Rasool Kareem (S.A) which is entirely strange and new for Rasool and Sahaba Kareem. Moreover it is introduced a long time after death of Rasool's (S. A). We all know that Rasool has completed his Deenul Islam and nobody can add or omit anything in the Deen.
